Apple wants OpenAI's battery and metal-finish files, and OpenAI calls that snooping
Apple has asked a federal court to order OpenAI to produce its research and development records on metal finishes, power management and battery functionality for consumer hardware, and to give Apple’s own forensic experts direct access to images of devices used by former Apple employees. OpenAI’s lawyers told the same court that the demand is "overbroad and premature, and an apparent attempt to snoop on a competitor".

Apple filed the trade secrets case in the Northern District of California on July 10, 2026. Image: Apple
Both positions appear in one joint submission on expedited discovery filed on September 18 in Apple Inc. v. Liu, the trade secrets case Apple brought in the Northern District of California on July 10. Judge Edward J. Davila, who asked the parties for the submission at a September 14 status conference, has not ruled on any of it, so every claim on either side is an argument a party is making, not a finding.
Apple’s requests reach into the hardware OpenAI has not released. The defendants include two former employees, Chang Liu and Tang Yew Tan, along with OpenAI and io Products, and the case follows a run of OpenAI hires from Apple’s hardware teams, among them the Vision Pro chief who left for OpenAI in June.
Apple says the defendants’ own experts made mistakes
Apple’s lawyers write that its forensic expert "has already uncovered several critical flaws in the analysis conducted by Defendants’ experts", naming two: a failure to locate files on Liu’s Mac Mini that Apple says were demonstrably used and stored there, and what Apple calls an incorrect conclusion that files of zero bytes, or with an empty kMDItemLastUsedDate field, were never accessed. "Giving Apple’s experts direct access to these forensic images is critical to understanding what other errors Defendants’ experts may have committed," the submission says.
The defendants read the same machine differently. They have told the court that "all 37 files Apple identifies as ‘Apple files’ are zero-byte files on Liu’s Mac Mini, strongly suggesting that Liu never opened, copied, or otherwise interacted with them".
Apple’s argument for the hardware documents is that the defendants raised the subject first, by arguing they "developed their own standard metal finishes" through their own trials rather than from Apple material. Apple says it is not asking for "a complete technical record of OpenAI’s development of any technology", only for records on "metal finishes, power management, or battery functionality".
The defendants want a neutral to hold the forensic images
They call that a "one-sided fishing expedition to gain litigation advantage" and say Apple’s requests reach the merits of the case and beyond. They want the images produced to a forensic neutral under an agreed protocol, with search terms and privilege filtering, rather than handed to Apple’s experts with what they describe as complete access to entire devices.
Their sharpest objection is about order of play. Producing OpenAI’s development records now, they argue, "requires OpenAI to reveal its trade secrets before Apple has revealed its own", which are the subject of the lawsuit. The defendants also tell the court that Apple served 165 document requests and 38 interrogatories on September 10, the day discovery opened, on top of the expedited set attached to its August motion.
The defendants tell the court no device ships before the end of February 2027
The defendants do put a date on the product, while arguing that Apple loses nothing by waiting. Apple will get the same material "well before any device ships", they say, "which will occur no earlier than the end of February 2027", citing a filing in iyO Inc. v. io Products, the separate trademark case in the same court. That date is a line in the defendants’ half of a discovery brief, not an OpenAI announcement.
OpenAI has announced no release date, and the submission says nothing about what the device is or does. The letter Sam Altman and Jony Ive published when io merged with OpenAI in July 2025 names no product either.
Both sides refer to the October 14 hearing on Apple’s preliminary injunction request, and Apple wants the images in hand before it. The public docket carries no order on the dispute, which leaves the September 18 filing as two sets of assertions.