“We had to prove them wrong”: Skyrim lead remembers the doubts around Fallout 3
Bethesda’s decision to make Fallout 3 did not convince everyone straight away. Former Bethesda designer Bruce Nesmith remembers a vocal group of fans who worried about what a new developer would do with the series, and says the team felt it had something to prove.
“We had to prove them wrong,” Nesmith said in an interview with The Examined Game, reported by PC Gamer. He believes Fallout 3 went on to win over many sceptics, even if not every long-time fan agreed with its direction.
Nesmith was also a lead designer on Skyrim. His comments offer a look at the human side of taking over a beloved series, when the team making the next game knows the audience is watching closely.

Fallout 3 was released in 2008. Image: Bethesda / Steam
Why fans were worried
The earlier Fallout games had established a very different style of role-playing. Bethesda’s Fallout 3, released in 2008, brought the series into a first-person open world. For some players, that was an exciting change; for others, the older approach remained the appeal.

Bethesda took the series in a different direction with Fallout 3. Image: Bethesda / Steam
Nesmith recalled strong objections from part of the community. He also acknowledged that harsh criticism can feel personal to the people making a game, even when they try to separate themselves from it.
PC Gamer notes that his recollection blends together references from different points in the series’ history. In particular, Skyrim arrived after Fallout 3, and Obsidian’s Fallout: New Vegas came later too. That is worth keeping in mind when placing the comments on a timeline.

The game is available on several older platforms and PC. Image: Bethesda / Steam
A disagreement that has not disappeared
Nesmith’s view is that the best response was to make the strongest game the team could. His belief that Bethesda won over some critics does not mean every original-series fan changed their mind. The debate over what a Fallout game should be remains part of the series’ identity.
If you want to revisit the game for yourself, Steam lists Fallout 3 on PC. Amazon also lists a PlayStation 3 copy; make sure you have the correct console and check the seller and condition before ordering.
For a very different take on the same universe, we recently covered Fallout: Factions in mixed reality.
Image credits: Bethesda / PC Gamer; Bethesda / Steam.
Note: Links to online stores in articles can be so-called affiliate links. If you buy through this link, MIXED receives a commission from the provider. For you the price does not change.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.