The Ninth Circuit will hear Valve's Steam terms appeal, and six users filed their own

The Ninth Circuit will hear Valve's Steam terms appeal, and six users filed their own

The Ninth Circuit granted Valve permission to appeal on September 16, and five days later six Steam users filed a notice of appeal of their own. Valve is appealing a ruling that the retroactive forum-selection clause in its September 2024 Steam Subscriber Agreement was likely unconscionable, and the six are appealing two separate orders that refused to confirm arbitration awards they had obtained against the company.

Steam Controller, Steam Machine and Steam Frame side by side

Valve's Steam Controller, Steam Machine and Steam Frame. Image: Valve

"The petition for permission to appeal is granted," Circuit Judges VanDyke and Sung wrote, citing 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b), the provision that lets an appeals court take a question before the case below has finished. Valve filed its notice two days later and the appeal was docketed as No. 26-6092, carrying a $605 fee, an opening brief due October 28 and an answering brief due November 27.

Nothing has been decided. Permission to appeal under section 1292(b) sends a question up early; it is not a ruling on that question, and the district court case is stayed until the Ninth Circuit answers it.

Valve is appealing the ruling on its 2024 terms

The district court denied Valve's motion for a preliminary injunction on May 27, holding that the updated agreement's retroactive forum-selection clause is "likely unconscionable, and so unenforceable, as applied to Defendants." Judge Jamal N. Whitehead certified that order for appeal on July 30 and stayed the case, recording that Valve frames the controlling question as "whether Valve's adoption of new contract terms in September 2024 was unconscionable as to the Defendants."

Certifying the question was not a change of mind. "The Court remains convinced that the retroactive forum-selection clause Valve presented to Defendants was likely procedurally and substantively unconscionable," the order says, while noting that the judge had told both sides at argument that neither was sitting "on comfortable ground."

Six named users appeal the orders that blocked their awards

Gregory Fish, Ethan Lefebvre, Christian Graber, Jeremy Lucas, Alec Birenbaum and Lance Vicente filed their notice on September 21, appealing the district court's July 24 and July 29 orders, which denied their motions to confirm arbitration awards. Their filing is a separate appeal rather than a cross-appeal, and names Valve's 26-6092 as a previous appeal in the case.

Two days later their lawyers asked the district court to confirm the notice was in time. "The Ninth Circuit granted Valve permission to appeal on September 16, 2026; Valve filed its notice of appeal on September 18; and Consumer-Defendants filed their notice three days later, on September 21," the motion says, arguing that Rule 4(a)(3) gave them 14 days from the first notice of appeal and that the rule does not require a second party to appeal the same order as the first.

The docket now groups 358 appellees under one name

On September 24 the Ninth Circuit ordered the case processed as a Large Party Case. Rather than list every respondent, the appellees in the list attached to that order "will proceed under the grouping name of: Users of Valve's Video Game Platform, Steam," and that list runs to 358 names, beginning with Thomas Abbruzzese, whose name the district court case still carries.

Valve brought the case in the Western District of Washington on October 18, 2024. The users' motion quotes the district court describing Valve's "tactical decision to name 624 individual respondents" and finding that its "filing and refiling of motions, renoting the petition, piecemeal withdrawals, and service issues" had "created needless complications."

The July 30 order stayed the district court case pending the Ninth Circuit's decision whether to take the appeal, and told the parties to file a joint status report within 14 days of that decision. That decision came on September 16, and the next date on the calendar is Valve's opening brief on October 28.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *