“We penalised shooting”: Indiana Jones developer explains The Great Circle's combat

“We penalised shooting”: Indiana Jones developer explains The Great Circle's combat

MachineGames built its reputation on the gun-heavy Wolfenstein series, so making an Indiana Jones game that encourages players to put firearms away presented an unusual challenge. Design director Jens Andersson has explained how the team made melee combat an appealing alternative in Indiana Jones and the Great Circle.

In an interview with FRVR, Andersson said the studio slowed reloading and made improvised fighting easier to pick up. The aim was to nudge players towards a style of combat that felt appropriate for Indy without making the guns themselves feel bad.

The approach also came with a late addition: breakable weapons. According to Andersson, that system helped the team turn ordinary objects into tempting tools during a fight.

Indiana Jones wearing a fedora in The Great Circle

MachineGames wanted its combat to suit an Indiana Jones adventure. Image: MachineGames / Bethesda / Steam

The team considered a wanted system inspired by GTA

Andersson told FRVR that MachineGames worried players would pick up a gun and clear an entire area with it. One idea considered during development was a wanted-style system in which shooting someone would bring reinforcements.

Instead, the released game encourages players to make use of their surroundings. Andersson said guns still needed to feel satisfying, but long reloads could make grabbing a nearby object the quicker response when enemies closed in.

“We penalised shooting so much in that game,” he said, while explaining that accessible melee combat helped the team solve the problem. He acknowledged that the approach frustrated some players as well as appealing to others.

Indy holds a whip while facing two guards

The whip is one of Indy's tools in the released game. Image: MachineGames / Bethesda / Steam

Breakable objects helped make improvised fights feel natural

The design director said the breakable-weapons system was introduced late and proved effective enough to encourage more unusual objects. That fits the film character's habit of adapting to whatever happens to be within reach, rather than relying on a single weapon.

The idea was not to remove every challenge from a fight. Andersson distinguished between making melee easy to understand and making the combat itself easy to win.

There is a useful lesson here for anyone who found the game's firearms awkward: that friction was part of a broader design choice. It does not mean shooting is impossible, or that every player has to approach an encounter in the same way.

A mechanical puzzle in Indiana Jones and the Great Circle

The Great Circle also includes exploration and puzzles. Image: MachineGames / Bethesda / Steam

The game is available across PC and major consoles

Bethesda lists The Great Circle for PC, Xbox Series X and S, PlayStation 5 and Nintendo Switch 2. Amazon also has an Xbox Series X edition from a third-party seller. The Xbox store also sells a digital edition. I recommend comparing the seller, edition and price before ordering, especially if you do not need a disc.

In 2025, MIXED also covered a fan-made VR mod for The Great Circle, a separate way enthusiasts were experimenting with the game.

Image credit: MachineGames / Bethesda / Steam.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *