Codex's Code Review sends a comment to GitHub before you submit the review

Codex's Code Review sends a comment to GitHub before you submit the review

Codex can now read a GitHub pull request inside ChatGPT and help write the review, and OpenAI's documentation for it carries one warning worth reading before the first attempt: "posting in Summary or Changes sends the comment to the source provider immediately, without waiting for Submit review."

ChatGPT running in a browser window with the sidebar showing Library, Projects, Scheduled and Plugins

Code Review is a plugin, and ChatGPT lists installed plugins in its sidebar. Image: OpenAI

The advice that goes with it is blunt. "Keep drafts in chat until you're ready," OpenAI says, because a comment typed into either of those views is not a draft at all: it lands on the pull request before the reviewer has settled on a verdict.

The feature arrived in ChatGPT's release notes dated September 29, as a Code Review plugin "on supported desktop and web experiences". GitHub support is generally available, and OpenAI says "GitLab merge request support in Code Review is in preview".

Talking to Codex posts nothing

The split between the chat and the panes is the part to learn. "Reviewing a pull request in chat doesn't post comments, approve it, or merge it. You choose which findings to share," OpenAI says, and Submit review is where a human picks Comment, Approve or Request changes and sends it on.

Codex will draft the comment if asked, and OpenAI tells reviewers to "Check the draft's file and line references before posting", which is a polite way of saying the model can point at the wrong line. Nothing in the documentation gives an accuracy figure for its findings.

Automatic reviews can land before the author opens the request

With the ChatGPT Codex connector, repository permissions and automatic reviews switched on, "Codex can review a GitHub pull request before you open it", and the comments "appear on GitHub and in Code Review". OpenAI adds that "Cloud review doesn't require you to create or manage a cloud environment", and that those automatic reviews are separate from anything started in a pull request's chat.

For work that has not reached a pull request yet, the same review runs locally. Typing /review in the Codex CLI, the desktop app or the IDE extension offers a review against a base branch or a review of uncommitted changes, and OpenAI says "Codex reports prioritized findings without changing your working tree". The pane needs the project to sit inside a Git repository.

The rest of the pane, and its gaps

A personal inbox filters GitHub pull requests by Assigned to me, Assigned to my team and Authored by me, files can be marked as viewed one at a time, and a Stack control opens a dependent pull request when Code Review finds a run of them. Standing review criteria go in a Review instructions field, with Comic book, Visualization and PDF offered as presets that, in OpenAI's wording, "add a suggested instruction" rather than produce anything themselves.

One documented gap: "Editing pull request descriptions with attached images isn't supported in Code Review," and OpenAI says to open the request on GitHub for that. No price, no plan list beyond supported desktop and web surfaces, and no claim that Codex approves or merges on its own, since every decision in the documentation is the reviewer's.

Codex already appears inside other companies' tools, including Android Studio's canary builds. Code Review goes the other way, bringing the pull request into ChatGPT, with a post control that does not wait for the reviewer's verdict.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *